Inverness in the running to become UK’s ugliest city
By Iain Ramage – Press and Journal
Published: 25/01/2010
The Highland capital is a contender to be named the UK’s ugliest city. A panel of architects and designers included Inverness in the nominations for the UK-wide Carbuncle Awards.
It makes the list for the “monstrous” design of the city centre and “mushrooming suburban sprawl”.
Cumbernauld, Glenrothes and Coatbridge are among past recipients of the award, which used to be restricted to Scotland.
People in Inverness greeted the nomination with a mixture of anger and acceptance last night.
An awards spokesman said the Highland capital had been dubbed “Tulloch town” by some critics due to the local developer’s dominance and highlighted earlier “box-like monstrosities” in the city centre.
There was a degree of acceptance of the criticism yesterday – but optimism that things would change.
City provost Jimmy Gray said: “The 1960s Bridge Street buildings are probably not the most attractive, but to say Inverness is anywhere near the ugliest in the UK is utter nonsense. Most people who visit think it’s an extremely attractive place.”
His deputy, Alex Graham, agreed, insisting Inverness was an attractive city with tremendous charm.
Local SNP councillor John Finnie was equally surprised.
He offered to escort panel members around the city to show them “the many wonderful historic sites” Inverness has to offer.
Labour councillor John Holden said the council had inherited a lot of poorly designed buildings but had attempted to redress that.
Barrie Haycock, of local pressure group Planning Watch, said it was only a matter of time before Inverness was singled out for such an award. He said: “Unfortunately, Highland Council seems to have adopted a policy of chasing planning gain monies rather than developing integrated communities for the benefit of those who choose to live in the area.”
He added that millions of pounds were spent on the Inverness Streetscape project while surrounding streets remained pockmarked with decaying buildings.
Inverness South community council member Liz Gilchrist added: “In the haste to make Inverness a city, it has been developed into a sprawling mass, losing its identity.”
Thomas Prag, another Lib Dem city councillor, disputed the carbuncle tag but urged planners and colleagues to be more imaginative.
He said: “A lot of estates were built in a hurry because the demand was there. But we’re beginning to put that right and the Housing Expo is a hugely positive sign that we now know better.”
Urban Realm, the architectural magazine behind the awards, promotes the event as “a force for good and a real motivator” to transform cities. The winner will be decided by public vote.
Certainly it is sad to read this about our city, but, I have to agree it has become an ugly, poor and dirty looking city centre, full of charity shops, pubs and drunks. The Council should have made the clean-up of the buildings a priority over badly done expensive paving and ugly sculpture.
The condition of the roads and pavement surfaces all around the city are in a disgraceful and dangerous state of disrepair. This is due to the cheap method of re-surfacing, using a thin layer of tar sprinkled with grit, which has proved to be false economy, and, the constant badly done patching. This all adds to the look of impoverishment Inverness now has.
Come on Highland Council, get the basics right.